Section 4 of 7
CSLB Liens and Other Remedies Practice Questions
10 free practice questions on liens and other remedies, part of the Insurance and Liens section (about 12% of the exam). Try each one, then open the answer: every choice is explained and the law is quoted.
Questions and answers
- Insurance and Liens
1. A subcontractor will supply labor and materials on a private home project. Under Civil Code section 8200, to whom must it give preliminary notice before it can record a lien claim?
- A. Only the direct contractor that hired it, and no one else
- B. The owner, the direct contractor, and any construction lender
- C. Only the county recorder where the property is located
- D. Only the owner, and only if the owner lives in the home
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: B
A. Only the direct contractor that hired it, and no one else
Wrong: notice only to the hiring contractor is not enough; section 8200 also requires notice to the owner or reputed owner and to any construction lender.
B. The owner, the direct contractor, and any construction lender
Correct answer
Right: section 8200 requires preliminary notice to the owner or reputed owner, the direct contractor or reputed direct contractor, and the construction lender, if any, before recording a lien claim.
C. Only the county recorder where the property is located
Wrong: a preliminary notice is given to the owner, the direct contractor, and any construction lender, not recorded with the county recorder.
D. Only the owner, and only if the owner lives in the home
Wrong: section 8200 requires notice to the owner or reputed owner, the direct contractor, and any construction lender, so notice to the owner alone is not enough.
Explanation
Civil Code section 8200 says that before recording a lien claim, giving a stop payment notice, or claiming against a payment bond, a claimant must give preliminary notice to three persons. They are the owner or reputed owner, the direct contractor or reputed direct contractor, and the construction lender, if there is one. Giving notice only to the hiring contractor or only to the owner is not enough. A preliminary notice is given to these persons, not recorded with the county recorder.
Sources
Civ. Code §8200(a)
before recording a lien claim, giving a stop payment notice, or asserting a claim against a payment bond, a claimant shall give preliminary notice to the following persons:
View source: Civ. Code §8200(a)Official site for Civ. Code §8200(a) (opens in a new tab)
Civ. Code §8200(a)
(1) The owner or reputed owner. (2) The direct contractor or reputed direct contractor to which the claimant provides work, either directly or through one or more subcontractors. (3) The construction lender or reputed construction lender, if any.
View source: Civ. Code §8200(a)Official site for Civ. Code §8200(a) (opens in a new tab)
- Insurance and Liens
2. A direct contractor finished its contract. The whole work of improvement was completed on May 25. The owner records a notice of completion on June 1. Under Civil Code section 8412, what is the deadline for the direct contractor to record a claim of lien?
- A. 30 days after June 1
- B. 60 days after June 1
- C. 90 days after June 1
- D. 120 days after June 1
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: B
A. 30 days after June 1
The 30-day period applies to claimants other than the direct contractor, such as subcontractors. A direct contractor gets 60 days after the owner records a notice of completion.
B. 60 days after June 1
Correct answer
A direct contractor must record before the earlier of 90 days after completion or 60 days after the owner records a notice of completion. Sixty days after June 1 comes before 90 days after the May 25 completion, so the deadline is 60 days after June 1.
C. 90 days after June 1
The 90-day period runs from completion of the work of improvement (May 25), not from the June 1 notice. Also, the deadline is the earlier of the two times, and 60 days after June 1 comes first.
D. 120 days after June 1
120 days after June 1 is not one of the two times in section 8412, and it is later than both of them. The deadline is the earlier of 90 days after completion or 60 days after the notice of completion.
Explanation
Civil Code section 8412 says a direct contractor must record its claim of lien before the earlier of 90 days after completion of the work of improvement, or 60 days after the owner records a notice of completion. Here, 60 days after the June 1 notice comes before 90 days after the May 25 completion. So the deadline is 60 days after June 1. The 30-day period applies to claimants other than the direct contractor, such as subcontractors. Neither 90 nor 120 days after June 1 is the earlier of the two deadlines.
Sources
Civ. Code §8412
A direct contractor may not enforce a lien unless the contractor records a claim of lien after the contractor completes the direct contract, and before the earlier of the following times:
View source: Civ. Code §8412Official site for Civ. Code §8412 (opens in a new tab)
Civ. Code §8412
(b) Sixty days after the owner records a notice of completion or cessation.
View source: Civ. Code §8412Official site for Civ. Code §8412 (opens in a new tab)
Civ. Code §8412(a)
(a) Ninety days after completion of the work of improvement.
View source: Civ. Code §8412(a)Official site for Civ. Code §8412(a) (opens in a new tab)
- Insurance and Liens
3. A material supplier on a private job gave its preliminary notice on time. It now wants to give the construction lender a stop payment notice. Under Civil Code section 8508, what timing rule must the stop payment notice also meet to be valid?
- A. It must be given before the lien recording deadline ends
- B. It must be given within 90 days after a lien is recorded
- C. It must be given only after the owner approves it in writing
- D. It must be given only after the whole project is finished
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: A
A. It must be given before the lien recording deadline ends
Correct answer
Section 8508 makes a stop payment notice valid only if it is given before the time to record a claim of lien runs out. The supplier already gave its preliminary notice, so this is the remaining rule.
B. It must be given within 90 days after a lien is recorded
The 90-day period after recording is the deadline to sue to enforce a lien. It is not a timing rule for a stop payment notice.
C. It must be given only after the owner approves it in writing
The owner does not have to approve the stop payment notice. The rule is to give it before the lien recording deadline ends.
D. It must be given only after the whole project is finished
The claimant does not have to wait for the project to finish. The notice must be given before the lien recording deadline ends.
Explanation
Civil Code section 8508 says a stop payment notice is valid only if the claimant gave any required preliminary notice and gave the stop payment notice before the time to record a claim of lien runs out. The supplier already gave its preliminary notice, so the remaining rule is to act before the lien recording deadline ends. The 90-day period after recording is the deadline to sue to enforce a lien, not a stop payment notice rule. The owner does not have to approve the notice, and the claimant does not have to wait for the project to finish.
Sources
Civ. Code §8508(b)
The claimant gave the stop payment notice before expiration of the time within which a claim of lien must be recorded under Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 8400).
View source: Civ. Code §8508(b)Official site for Civ. Code §8508(b) (opens in a new tab)
Civ. Code §8530
A person that has a lien right under Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 8400) may give a construction lender a stop payment notice.
View source: Civ. Code §8530Official site for Civ. Code §8530 (opens in a new tab)
- Insurance and Liens
4. A subcontractor recorded a claim of lien on a commercial building 120 days ago. There was no extension of credit, and it never filed a lawsuit to enforce the lien. Under Civil Code section 8480, what may the owner do?
- A. Ask the CSLB to cancel the claim of lien from the record
- B. Record a notice of nonresponsibility to remove the lien
- C. Nothing, because the lien stays until the claim is paid
- D. Petition the court for an order releasing the property
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: D
A. Ask the CSLB to cancel the claim of lien from the record
The CSLB does not remove recorded liens. Under section 8480, the owner's step is to petition the court.
B. Record a notice of nonresponsibility to remove the lien
A notice of nonresponsibility is for an owner who did not contract for the work, and it must be given early, not after a lien is recorded.
C. Nothing, because the lien stays until the claim is paid
The lien does not last until the claim is paid. It expires if no action to enforce it is started within 90 days after it is recorded, and 120 days have passed here.
D. Petition the court for an order releasing the property
Correct answer
Section 8480 lets the owner petition the court for an order releasing the property when the claimant has not started an action within the section 8460 time of 90 days after recording. No lawsuit was filed in 120 days, so the owner may do this.
Explanation
Under Civil Code section 8460, a claimant must file an action to enforce a lien within 90 days after recording it, or the lien expires. Civil Code section 8480 lets the owner petition (ask) the court for a release order when the claimant did not start an action in that time. The CSLB does not remove recorded liens. A notice of nonresponsibility is for an owner who did not contract for the work, and it must be given early, not after a lien is recorded. The lien does not last until payment; it expires when the 90 days pass.
Sources
Civ. Code §8480(a)
The owner of property or the owner of any interest in property subject to a claim of lien may petition the court for an order to release the property from the claim of lien if the claimant has not commenced an action to enforce the lien within the time provided in Section 8460.
View source: Civ. Code §8480(a)Official site for Civ. Code §8480(a) (opens in a new tab)
Civ. Code §8460(a)
The claimant shall commence an action to enforce a lien within 90 days after recordation of the claim of lien. If the claimant does not commence an action to enforce the lien within that time, the claim of lien expires and is unenforceable.
View source: Civ. Code §8460(a)Official site for Civ. Code §8460(a) (opens in a new tab)
- Insurance and Liens
5. A subcontractor on a public works job gives the public entity a valid stop payment notice for $15,000. Under Civil Code section 9358, what must the public entity do?
- A. Withhold enough from the direct contractor to pay the claim
- B. Pay the subcontractor $15,000 at once from the contract funds
- C. Stop all work on the job until the claim is settled
- D. Send the notice to the payment bond surety and take no action
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: A
A. Withhold enough from the direct contractor to pay the claim
Correct answer
Section 9358 says that, on receipt of a stop payment notice, the public entity must withhold from the direct contractor enough money due or to become due to pay the claim. It may also hold back enough for its reasonable cost of any litigation over the notice.
B. Pay the subcontractor $15,000 at once from the contract funds
The statute does not tell the public entity to pay the claimant directly. Its duty is to withhold enough funds from the direct contractor to pay the claim.
C. Stop all work on the job until the claim is settled
The statute does not tell the public entity to stop the work. Its duty is to withhold enough funds from the direct contractor to pay the claim.
D. Send the notice to the payment bond surety and take no action
A payment bond is a separate remedy, and it does not replace the public entity's duty to withhold funds from the direct contractor.
Explanation
Civil Code section 9358 says that, on receipt of a stop payment notice, the public entity must withhold from the direct contractor enough money due or to become due to pay the claim. It may also hold back enough for its reasonable cost of any litigation over the notice. The statute does not tell the entity to pay the claimant directly or to stop the work. A payment bond is a separate remedy, and it does not replace the duty to withhold.
Source
Civ. Code §9358(a)
The public entity shall, on receipt of a stop payment notice, withhold from the direct contractor sufficient funds due or to become due to the direct contractor to pay the claim stated in the stop payment notice and to provide for the public entity's reasonable cost of any litigation pursuant to the stop payment notice.
View source: Civ. Code §9358(a)Official site for Civ. Code §9358(a) (opens in a new tab)
- Insurance and Liens
6. A subcontractor gives the construction lender an unbonded stop payment notice (a notice without a bond). No payment bond was recorded. Under Civil Code section 8536, must the lender withhold funds to pay the claim?
- A. Yes, it must withhold the full amount of the claim stated
- B. Yes, but it must withhold only one half of the claim
- C. No, it may choose not to, because the notice is unbonded
- D. No, because only an owner must ever withhold for a notice
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: C
A. Yes, it must withhold the full amount of the claim stated
Because the notice is unbonded, the lender may at its option elect not to withhold, so it is not required to withhold the full claim.
B. Yes, but it must withhold only one half of the claim
Nothing in section 8536 sets a half-claim amount. For an unbonded notice, withholding is the lender's choice.
C. No, it may choose not to, because the notice is unbonded
Correct answer
Correct. Section 8536 lets the construction lender, at its option, elect not to withhold funds when the stop payment notice is unbonded.
D. No, because only an owner must ever withhold for a notice
Section 8536 does apply to a construction lender, which must normally withhold enough to pay the claim. The lender may decline here only because the notice is unbonded.
Explanation
Civil Code section 8536 says a construction lender that receives a stop payment notice must normally withhold enough funds to pay the claim. But the lender may, at its option, choose not to withhold when the notice is unbonded. Here the notice has no bond, so withholding is the lender's choice. If the notice had been bonded, and no payment bond had been recorded first, the lender would have to withhold. Nothing in the statute sets a half-claim amount.
Sources
Civ. Code §8536(b)
The construction lender may, at its option, elect not to withhold funds in any of the following circumstances:
View source: Civ. Code §8536(b)Official site for Civ. Code §8536(b) (opens in a new tab)
Civ. Code §8536(b)(1)
The stop payment notice is unbonded.
View source: Civ. Code §8536(b)(1)Official site for Civ. Code §8536(b)(1) (opens in a new tab)
- Insurance and Liens
7. A construction lender holds $30,000 under stop payment notices. Two suppliers gave bonded notices, one a week before the other. Their claims add up to more than $30,000. There are no other notices. Under Civil Code section 8540, how is the $30,000 split?
- A. Each supplier gets a share in proportion to its claim
- B. The supplier that gave its notice first is paid in full
- C. Each supplier gets an equal half of the withheld funds
- D. The supplier that sued first to enforce its claim is paid first
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: A
A. Each supplier gets a share in proportion to its claim
Correct answer
Right: when the funds are not enough to pay all bonded claims in full, they are split pro rata, in the ratio that each claim bears to the total of all bonded claims.
B. The supplier that gave its notice first is paid in full
Wrong: pro rata distribution is made without regard to the order in which the stop payment notices were given, so giving notice first does not matter.
C. Each supplier gets an equal half of the withheld funds
Wrong: an equal split ignores the size of each claim. Each supplier's share is in the ratio its claim bears to the total of all bonded claims.
D. The supplier that sued first to enforce its claim is paid first
Wrong: pro rata distribution is made without regard to the order in which enforcement actions were started, so suing first does not matter.
Explanation
Civil Code section 8540 pays bonded stop payment notices first. If the funds are not enough to pay all bonded claims in full, the money is split pro rata, meaning in the ratio that each claim bears to the total of all bonded claims. The statute says this is done without regard to the order in which notices were given or lawsuits were started. So being first does not matter, and an equal split ignores the size of each claim.
Sources
Civ. Code §8540(a)(1)
If funds are insufficient to pay the claims of those persons in full, the funds shall be distributed pro rata among the claimants in the ratio that the claim of each bears to the aggregate of all claims for which a bonded stop payment notice is given.
View source: Civ. Code §8540(a)(1)Official site for Civ. Code §8540(a)(1) (opens in a new tab)
Civ. Code §8540(b)
Pro rata distribution under this section shall be made among the persons entitled to share in the distribution without regard to the order in which the person has given a stop payment notice or commenced an enforcement action.
View source: Civ. Code §8540(b)Official site for Civ. Code §8540(b) (opens in a new tab)
- Insurance and Liens
8. Before work began, the owner filed the direct contract with the county recorder. Later, the direct contractor asked a subcontractor to build a deck. The deck is not in the direct contract or any change to it. Under Civil Code section 8432, does the subcontractor's lien cover the deck work?
- A. Yes, because the direct contractor asked for the deck work
- B. Yes, because all authorized work on a site can be liened
- C. No, because subcontractors can never lien for extra work
- D. No, because the filed contract gave it notice of the scope
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: D
A. Yes, because the direct contractor asked for the deck work
Who asked for the work does not matter. Section 8432 says the lien does not cover work outside the direct contract or a change to it, whether or not a contractor authorized it, if the claimant had notice of the contract terms.
B. Yes, because all authorized work on a site can be liened
Not all authorized work can be liened. Under section 8432, work outside the direct contract or a change to it is not covered when the claimant had actual knowledge or constructive notice of the contract terms.
C. No, because subcontractors can never lien for extra work
This goes too far. Extra work can be covered when it is in a change to the direct contract, so subcontractors are not always barred.
D. No, because the filed contract gave it notice of the scope
Correct answer
Correct. Filing the contract with the county recorder before work began gave constructive notice of its terms, so the deck work, which is outside the contract and any change to it, is not covered by the lien.
Explanation
Civil Code section 8432 says a lien does not cover work that is not in the direct contract or a change to it, if the claimant knew or had constructive notice of the contract terms. Constructive notice means the law treats the person as knowing, even if it did not read the contract. Filing the contract with the county recorder before work begins gives that constructive notice. So the deck is not covered, even though the direct contractor asked for it. Extra work can be covered when it is in a change to the contract, so subcontractors are not always barred.
Sources
Civ. Code §8432(a)
A lien does not extend to work, whether or not the work is authorized by a direct contractor or subcontractor, if the work is not included in a direct contract or a modification of that contract, and the claimant had actual knowledge or constructive notice of the provisions of that contract or modification before providing the work.
View source: Civ. Code §8432(a)Official site for Civ. Code §8432(a) (opens in a new tab)
Civ. Code §8432(b)
The filing of a contract or modification of that contract with the county recorder, before the commencement of a work of improvement, is constructive notice of the provisions of the contract or modification to a person providing work on that work of improvement.
View source: Civ. Code §8432(b)Official site for Civ. Code §8432(b) (opens in a new tab)
- Insurance and Liens
9. Under Civil Code section 8204, when should a claimant give the preliminary notice for a private work of improvement?
- A. Within 10 days after it first furnishes work
- B. Within 20 days after it first furnishes work
- C. Within 30 days after it first furnishes work
- D. Within 90 days after it first furnishes work
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: B
A. Within 10 days after it first furnishes work
Wrong: section 8204 sets the deadline at 20 days after the claimant first furnishes work, not 10 days.
B. Within 20 days after it first furnishes work
Correct answer
Right: section 8204 says a preliminary notice shall be given not later than 20 days after the claimant first furnishes work on the work of improvement.
C. Within 30 days after it first furnishes work
Wrong: 30 days is a deadline for recording a claim of lien, not for the preliminary notice, which is due within 20 days after the claimant first furnishes work.
D. Within 90 days after it first furnishes work
Wrong: 90 days is a deadline for recording a claim of lien, not for the preliminary notice, which is due within 20 days after the claimant first furnishes work.
Explanation
Civil Code section 8204 says a preliminary notice shall be given not later than 20 days after the claimant first furnishes work on the work of improvement. Thirty and 90 days are deadlines for recording a claim of lien after a notice of completion or after completion, not for the preliminary notice. Ten days is not the deadline in section 8204.
Source
Civ. Code §8204(a)
A preliminary notice shall be given not later than 20 days after the claimant has first furnished work on the work of improvement.
View source: Civ. Code §8204(a)Official site for Civ. Code §8204(a) (opens in a new tab)
- Insurance and Liens
10. A material supplier first delivered materials to a job on March 1. It did not give a preliminary notice until April 10. Under Civil Code section 8204, for which materials may it record a lien?
- A. All materials it delivered, starting on March 1
- B. Materials delivered on or after March 21 only
- C. Materials delivered on or after April 10 only
- D. No materials, because its notice was given late
Show answerHide answer
Correct answer: B
A. All materials it delivered, starting on March 1
Wrong: because the notice was late, the supplier may record a lien only for work provided within 20 days before the notice and after, so deliveries before March 21 are not covered.
B. Materials delivered on or after March 21 only
Correct answer
Right: a late preliminary notice still allows a lien for work provided within 20 days before the notice was served and any time after. Twenty days before April 10 is March 21.
C. Materials delivered on or after April 10 only
Wrong: the lien is not limited to work after the notice date; it also covers work within 20 days before the notice, back to March 21.
D. No materials, because its notice was given late
Wrong: a late notice does not wipe out all lien rights; section 8204 lets the claimant give notice at any time afterward and lien work from 20 days before the notice onward.
Explanation
Civil Code section 8204 says a claimant who gives a late preliminary notice may still give it, but may record a lien only for work provided within 20 days before the notice was served, and after that. Twenty days before April 10 is March 21. So the supplier keeps lien rights for materials delivered on or after March 21, but loses them for earlier deliveries. A late notice does not wipe out all lien rights, and it does not limit the lien to work after the notice date.
Sources
Civ. Code §8204(a)
If work has been provided by a claimant who did not give a preliminary notice, that claimant shall not be precluded from giving a preliminary notice at any time thereafter.
View source: Civ. Code §8204(a)Official site for Civ. Code §8204(a) (opens in a new tab)
Civ. Code §8204(a)
be entitled to record a lien, give a stop payment notice, and assert a claim against a payment bond only for work performed within 20 days prior to the service of the preliminary notice, and at any time thereafter.
View source: Civ. Code §8204(a)Official site for Civ. Code §8204(a) (opens in a new tab)
Keep studying
Read the Section 4 study notes: Insurance and Liens